whiskey and met Charlie’s stare from across the kitchen. The game Reagan wanted to play for Theo was just as much for us as it was for them. The waiting, listening, and knowing what was happening, was driving us both insane. I’d been hard for hours, thinking about what was coming. I felt too hot and cold all at once, so turned on that I couldn’t think straight.
Charlie lifted his head as the first cries of pleasure leaked out of the bedroom. The gag he’d wrapped around Reagan’s head was pitiful and would do nothing against her voice. The woman was an angel in every way, but in the bedroom, she was a deviant in the best fucking way possible. She wasn’t afraid to take what she wanted and to let us hear how good it was. We’d never be able to live next to neighbors, which was more than fine by me. I wanted her to be able to walk around naked, so neighbors weren’t going to work for me.
Reagan’s throaty moans grew even louder and the sound of skin slapping skin rose. We’d been waiting for a while, giving Theo time to get into his rhythm. From the sounds coming from the bedroom, he’d found it.
Charlie braced his hands on the island and swore. “Jesus. She’s going to kill me.”
I nodded to the bedroom. “I can’t wait anymore.”
He inhaled sharply and chuckled darkly. “Now, let’s go see if we can look without touching for a while.”
“Goddammit.”
Outside the bedroom door, I took a deep breath and found it was easier to slip into character than I would’ve thought. Pushing open the door, I took in the sight of Theo driving into Reagan from behind. Gripping her hips, he was fucking her hard and deep, giving her just what she wanted.
“Damn. Look at this, Charlie.” I walked farther into the room and heard Charlie shut and lock the door behind himself. “No wonder she was screaming the walls down. You’re fucking the hell out of her.”
Theo froze, still deep inside Reagan. “What the fuck? You can’t be in here.”
Charlie moved around the bed and lowered himself into one of the chairs. “Why not? Your girl isn’t complaining.”
I stood just next to Reagan’s head and leaned down. “What’s that, honey? Don’t stop? Is that what you said?”
Theo’s mouth twisted up and I could tell he was having fun. He pulled out of Rea and paused at the moan she made. “Baby… You like it?”
I sat next to Charlie and studied the way Reagan’s eyes were dazed with need. She was close to a giant orgasm. I nodded to Theo. “From this end, she looks pretty fucking into it, man. How about you keep going? Don’t let your lady down.”
Theo pumped into her and Reagan let out a wild scream as she came. The gag barely muffled it and Theo’s grin was nearly feral as he gripped her ass. “You like that they’re watching you, baby? They’re seeing you come all over my dick. Is that what does it for you?”
Charlie unbuttoned his pants and pushed the zipper down. “Don’t worry. Just making room, sweetheart.”
Theo started thrusting harder again. “Look what you’re doing to them, Reagan. They’re hard from watching you get fucked.”
Reagan’s hands dug into the bedding, her eyes rolling as her orgasm stretched on and on. When Theo picked up his intense pace again, she dropped her head to the bed and screamed into the bed.
Theo swore as he reached up and gripped her shoulders, using the leverage to fuck her harder. “Fuck it. Let her see it. Jack yourselves in front of her. She should see what she does to you.”
Charlie and I played along, pulling our dicks out. Fucking my fist in front of Reagan wasn’t a hardship by any means. When her head snapped up to watch, I grunted. Just a look from her could affect me so strongly. Charlie swore, as lost to her as I was.
“Watch them, Rea. You see how hard you make them? They want to fuck you so badly. They’d do anything for a chance at this sweet pussy.” Theo lowered one of his hands to her wetness and then rubbed it over her ass. “You like this, don’t you, baby? You’re so wet. Feel my fingers slipping into your ass? That’s what they want to do to you. They want to fuck your ass, too, baby. Would you like that?”
Charlie stood up and stroked himself inches from Reagan’s face. “She wants it, man.”
I moved next to Charlie and pulled the gag out of her mouth. “Tell your boyfriend, baby. Tell him that you want him to share.”
Theo pumped his fingers into her ass faster. “Is that right, Rea? You want me to share you with these guys?”
Reagan came again, her orgasm squeezing her walls tight enough to make Theo cry out. When she could talk again, Reagan looked back at Theo and spoke with the sweetest voice. “I want what you want, Teddy. Do you want to share me? If you do, I’d do it. I’d do anything for you. I’d suck their cocks, if that’s what you wanted. Or, if you wanted to let them fuck me, that could be…fun…”
Theo pulled out and stepped back. “Fuck her. She needs it hard.”
Untying Reagan’s hands, I shifted her until I could settle under her. Then, lining our bodies up, I thrust up into her sweet core and felt just how wet our play had made her. Pulling her mouth down to mine, I kissed her while Charlie settled behind her. Stroking my tongue over hers, I nibbled it while gripping her ass and pulling her cheeks apart for Charlie. After teasing her for a minute, I felt him slowly ease into her ass, making her already tight walls clench down on my dick.
“You take their cocks beautifully, baby. How does it feel?” Theo stroked her face and fed her his thumb for her to suck while he spurred her on. “You’re letting them fuck your perfect pussy and tight little ass while your boyfriend watches. You’re only missing a dick in your mouth. Should I go find someone else or do you want mine?”
She sucked his thumb hard and then opened her mouth wide. “Yours. Please, let me have it.”
Theo swore like a sailor as he moved so he could slide his dick deep into her mouth. From my angle, I watched her throat bulge where she tried to take him even deeper. He gripped her head and fucked her mouth faster as he watched Charlie start to thrust into her ass.
We all moved, thrusting deep and hard into Reagan, giving her everything we had. I ran my hands all over her body, touching every part of her that I could. I listened to her moan around Theo’s dick and heard Charlie and Theo getting closer to coming. We’d perfected fucking Rea together and that time was no different. Her nails bit into my chest as we worked her body harder and Theo gave her no breaks as he hit that spot at the back of her throat more and more, pushing past it.
“Fuck! Are you going to come for them, Rea? Are you going to let them come inside of you?” Theo held her face and shouted as he pulled out until just the tip of his dick was still in her mouth. He muttered incoherently as I watched her throat move with each swallow as she drank his release down and still tongued him. “Goddammit, Reagan! This mouth!”
Charlie couldn’t hold his release after watching Theo. He moved harder and faster, forcing a scream from Reagan as he got rougher just before slamming deep and coming. Reagan came like a jet plane, her body squeezing down on us so hard that Charlie had to pull out and I had no chance of lasting. I gripped her ass hard and shot my load deep inside her, calling out her name as I did.
Reagan screamed and then sank her teeth into my chest, leaving yet another mark. When her orgasm finally waned, she collapsed on my chest, both of us sweaty, and panted against my throat.
“Happy fucking birthday to me.” Theo fell next to us, his forearm over his eyes. “I might be dead. I think you sucked the life out of me, baby.”
Reagan gave a weak chuckle and shivered as my dick pulsed inside her. “Stop moving it, Auggie. I’m broken. No more.”
I stroked her back and held her tight. “That’s involuntary. You giggle and it happens. Sue me. Are you okay, though?”
She kissed my chest and sighed. “What’s better than okay? Great? Awesome? Fucking amazing?”
Charlie fell next to us and threw his arm over Reagan’s back. “The kid is going to have a mouth like a sailor when it comes out.”
I grinned. “Clearly my spawn, then.”
Theo laughed. “Calm down, SEAL boy.”
Reagan giggled and then grunted when my dick reacted. “Don’t start. If I have to listen to one more fight about being a SEAL or not being a SEAL, I’m going to be raising this baby as a single mom.”
Charlie growled. “You’re never leaving us, woman.”
“Who said leaving? I’m going to murder you.”
I snorted and raised my eyebrows in surprise when Reagan’s walls pulsed around me. “Oh, yeah?”
She blushed and shrugged. “I guess your stupid laugh does it for me, too.”
Theo groaned. “Don’t compliment him when we’re arguing about SEAL things, baby.”
“No, do. Compliment me, baby.” I grinned and planted a kiss on her chin. “Give me all the compliments.”
She giggled and climbed out of bed, leaving us all sitting up, staring after her. Standing naked in front of us with her rounded belly, she was the most beautiful thing I’d ever seen. “You know what I’m going to want for my birthday fun?”
“What?”
“Three actual strangers if you three keep up your fighting.”
I looked over at Theo and then Charlie. “Did she just threaten us?”
Charlie nodded. “I think she did.”
“I don’t think we should take this. Not lying down, anyway.” Theo jumped out of bed. “Come on, SEAL boy. I know you have some fancy knots. Let’s tie her up and gag her again.”
Reagan screamed and ran when we all started chasing her, her hair flying behind her as she went. Then, like the wild child she was for us, she threw open the door and ran outside, leading us on a naked chase around the property. When we caught her, we took her again, gentler, showing her just how much we loved her. She cried out our names under the stars, our ring on her finger, our baby in her belly.
It wasn’t until I was sitting with Theo at Landings the next morning, waiting on Charlie and Reagan to join us for breakfast, that I realized the flaw to Reagan’s outside fun time.
Pearl Beerman stopped next to our table, giggling like a schoolgirl as she looked at us. “I tried to stop by your party to tell Reagan that I know who’s been defacing the chip.”
Theo smiled, the unaware bastard not picking up on Pearl’s weirdness. “Oh? Who is it?”
She turned her focus on me and snorted. “Never seen three trouser snakes bouncing around like that before. I thought I was at the zoo for a second there.”
Theo spit out the coffee he’d just drank. I felt my face burn an unflattering shade of red. The busy patio around us fell quiet.
“Jonah’s nephew is a police sketch artist. I’m going to meet with him and see if he’s any good later.” Pearl giggled even more and then slapped her knee and slowly backed away. “Tell Reagan to come see me if she wants to know about the chip. And if she wants a copy of the sketch. He also does those vacation town drawings where they make your head really big and your body all little. Only, I’m going to tell him to do it a little differently. Snake forward, if you know what I mean.”
Theo bit his fist and nodded like he was listening to the most normal thing in the world. I noticed that he was also blushing.
Pearl practically skipped away, clearly having a wonderful day.
Reagan and Charlie showed up a few minutes later and Reagan instantly saw our faces and laughed. “What happened? You two look like you just got caught with your pants down.”
Theo groaned and I bit down roughly into a biscuit, talking around it. “This is all your fault!”
“What did I do?”
“You had us running around outside naked like a bunch of lunatics!” Theo’s raised voice filled in any Landings customers who’d missed Pearl’s announcement. “Pearl saw us! She’s on her way to a sketch artist as we speak!”
Reagan kept a straight face for all of ten seconds before she threw her head back and laughed so hard she was crying and then had to run inside to pee. While she was gone, Charlie shuddered and stared down at his lap. I nodded, feeling his pain.
The joke wasn’t complete until the chef, a friend from school, sent our pancakes out with penis-shaped whipped cream drawings, which set Reagan off again. Seeing her laugh like that, so happy and carefree, I knew that having my swinging penis immortalized by Pearl Beerman and a police sketch artist was worth it. There would never be anything that wouldn’t be worth the cost for Reagan to be happy.
She spotted me smiling at her after a while and smiled back at me, biting her lip. “What?”
“I fucking love you.”
She blinked away sudden tears. “I fucking love you, too.”
